It started with a pair of last-minute costumes; hers, a blueberry (as part of a fruit salad), and his, a skeleton, complete with a fully-painted face. Neither knew the hostess of the party in Bushwick, Brooklyn, but were both there as friends of friends. A chance encounter and a conversation about writing and counseling ensued, leading to Kyle asking Katie for her number. A week later, Katie found Kyle near the entrance to the Roosevelt Island Tram, despite not really knowing what he looked like, for their first date. After four Halloweens and many dates, they will be back in Brooklyn for a different type of party.