We met through a mutual friend on the way to a party — Katie showed up fully committed to the country theme, and Garrick showed up late and not even close to on theme. He claims it was love at first sight; she thinks he was just impressed by her commitment to the outfit. Not long after, he asked her on a date, and before they knew it, they were spending every weekend together at Ohio State games. A few months later, they made it official, and the rest is history.