We had our first date at the Post Office Cafe in Babylon. We bonded over the Jeep life, both of our dogs being named Holly, and how basically everyone in our family is named Rob. Having all those similarities made both of us hopeful, but we knew we were a great match when a few weeks after our first date Rob was a true champ taking care of Katie. Katie had to cut her birthday celebration short due to her typical upset stomach, but Rob didn’t run. In fact, he stayed the whole night just hanging out and talking to Katie. They made plans to go out again when she was feeling better, but just him staying that night made her feel a little better.