The first time Kaitlyn and Nick met, they were two coaches on the sideline. A few years later, Nick and Kaitlyn met online and hit it off right away!

Nick proposed to Kaitlyn at the Capital Grille Steakhouse in Pittsburgh, PA. Nick organized the evening with Kaitlyn's parents to ensure that her family could be there. Although the restaurant almost gave away the surprise (multiple times), Nick proposed to Kaitlyn after dinner surrounded by her family!