Kaitlyn and Jesus met on March 9, 2019, at a place where only true love happens. You've guessed it, Emerson Biggins in Downtown Wichita! Surprisingly, they had never crossed paths until that time even though both shared many of the same friends and acquaintances. Both were there to celebrate a mutual friend's birthday, Dani (Kaitlyn's cousin Alex's future wife). Shortly after Alex introduced them, Jesus went to the bathroom and texted Alex, "Hey man, is your cousin single? 👀", to which Alex replied, "Yes haha you should talk to her bro, she's really nice!". So Jesus did, and asked her for her number. They talked all night about pretty much everything, although Jesus doesn't remember all the details due to being very nervous not to sound silly, and several vodka tonics along the way at Pumphouse and XY. Like something out of a fairytale, Kaitlyn and Jesus left together at the end of the night and walked to a nearby restaurant to have a delicious quesadilla with the rest of their friends. Kaitlyn will be in for a surprise as this was the beginning of many "cheesy" moments they will eventually share together. Finally, their night ended by Kaitlyn dropping the guys off at Alex's apartment in Downtown Wichita. A couple days later, Jesus made the (soon-to-be-second) best decision of his life: He texted Kaitlyn.