Yes, you read that right, Kaitlyn and James met on an online dating app. After matching, they made plans to meet at a local dive bar. Even though they knew nothing much of each other besides their first names, upon meeting they each felt like they were greeting an old friend. They sat down with a few beers and immediately dug into their favorite conspiracy theories. Everything from ghost stories, alien invasions, even bigfoot. It was silly, but it was one of the best first “dates” either of them had ever been on. A week later James asks Kaitlyn out for an "official" first date. Kaitlyn left her office to find James eagerly waiting outside with a single red rose. (Which he double checked with her roommate ahead of time to make sure what flowers she liked, thanks Jordan!) They headed across the street to have a picnic lunch in the governor's garden. Five years later, they get to say "I do" in that same place.