It was the same weekend Scott asked Justine's parents for their blessing. When they got back to their apartment, Scott 'fake' proposed with a piece of coal that he had given her last Christmas. Once the joke was over, he swapped the coal with the engagement ring. At first, Justine thought he was joking again, but Scott begged her to stand up so that he could get on one knee and propose for real this time. Justine was shocked and of course said yes!