Kara and Josh met the old-fashioned way...online. They first matched on Bumble back in 2021, but life had other plans—Kara canceled their first date after deciding to become ‘exclusive’ with someone else. Thankfully, they were given a second chance on Hinge in 2023, when Kara instantly recognized Josh’s profile. She texted the number saved years before as “Josh Bumble,” having broken her own rule of never storing a date’s number so soon. From there, they skipped the small talk and decided to meet for a low-stakes walk in the park. What started as a quick hello effortlessly turned into a drink, then dinner—the very thing they had both promised never to do on a first date. But despite carefully made “rules,” it seems God had other plans: that spontaneous evening became their last first date.