Volleyball or Tiki Bar. The water may be warmer than the air... Don't say we didn't warn ya!
Check out downtown Cedarburg (where Johnny is from) and see how cute a Hallmark town is in real life! You can grab a cup of coffee at Cedarburg Roastery or Fiddleheads, pop into Armbruster Jewelers where Johnny's family has purchased all of their engagement rings, or hang out along the river at Rebellion Brewing :)
Sheboygan has a quaint downtown area with shops along the canal where you can sail, rent a pontoon, or kayak. Blue Harbor is situated right on Lake Michigan with public beach access and an indoor waterpark. We had dinner at "The Black Pig" and really enjoyed it! The scallops were 10/10.