We're so excited to celebrate with you

A week or two before Halloween, a mutual friend told Itana that an old high school friend was interested in meeting her, so after a few failed attempts and a facetime call to prove Jeremy really existed, they finally met at the Homecoming Pep Rally, exchanging names and awkward hellos. They met up again after a late-night party and talked until the early morning.

They planned a weekend in Rochester so that Titi Celia and Itana could celebrate their birthday weekend together. Jeremy got Titi a gift: once she opened it, out she pulled an aquamarine Coca-Cola bottle in an ode to her favorite brand, which had a paper sticking out from the top. Once she unrolled it, she cupped her face and said, "Oh yes! I will be your aunt." Confused, Itana turned to look at Jeremy, only to find him down on one knee. Becoming emotional, she cried and said, "Yes!"