We met the old fashioned way, on a dating app! Janine realized that the man of her dreams wasn't going to come walking into her living room, and when she saw Jay's photo with his dog, she made a bold move and ♡'d it. Jay had recently moved back to Pittsburgh from the Big Apple and was looking for restaurant recommendations. It was all very polite, until Jay's true personality started to come out - witty remarks sprinkled with sarcasm. Beyond the mutual right swipes, it was a match. From there they were pretty inseparable. Janine knew Jay was the one long before he got down on one knee, and the feeling was collective.