Despite going to the same school, having similar friends and probably attending the same parties, Michael and Tonya didn't get the chance to meet until years after college. It was on that rainy Saturday night in March, in a charming Italian restaurant on the east side of Manhattan where Michael and Tonya had their first date. Sounds hopelessly romantic and in typical rom-com fashion, it ended abruptly with a quick trip to Hoboken medical center.

On a beautiful night in Chiusi, Italy, while preparing pizza dinner in the homes brick oven, Michael proposed to Tonya.