Garrett and Holly met at mutual friend Cory Barton's birthday in December 2012. Holly was recently 21 so when Cory greeted her with, "Holly, would you like a girly drink?" she of course said yes. Cory followed up by saying, "Garrett makes girly drinks. Garrett, make Holly a drink!" It wasn't until a year later when Holly and Garrett met again in what looked like a double date at Hacienda; an evil plan set in motion by Cory and his girlfriend Lauren. When Garrett contacted Holly for a date afterwards, she explicitly said, "I don't work weekends and I like your beard." They were engaged almost four years later.