Lindsey and Garret met at the University of Arizona during the fall of 2012. Lindsey had just made the club soccer team and was asked by a friend to go to her neighbors house. Reluctant to go because she hadn't showered from practice, she begrudgingly agreed, regardless of how red and sweaty she was. Upon arriving, she noticed three men get out of the car to go inside the house that she and her friend were going to. Lindsey remembers meeting two boys first (Garrett's roommate and his brother, Grady) and then finally Garrett. They didn't talk much as Garrett was on the quiet side, but as soon they left, Lindsey turned to her friend and said "That guy is going to be my boyfriend one day." Her friend said "Good luck, Garrett doesn't date anyone."