With Tinder profiles, Elisa had 1 major rule: If you can't see their full face, then it's an automatic 'no.' Looking at Henry's Tinder profile pictures, every single picture had sunglasses on. But, his bio saved him: "If you ever see a mysterious, suave man staring longingly into the distance, that's not me. I'll be the one off to his left running away from a goose with a corndog in my hand." Throwing Elisa and her sister into a laughing fit, they swiped 'yes.' -- After chatting over a couple of weeks -- Henry and Elisa set their first date for September 13, 2018 at Falora Pizza. Getting ready for the date, Henry sent a text saying that traffic was bad so he'll be a little late. Elisa was about to head out the door, but upon receiving the text, she decided to wait a few extra minutes and watch some TV before heading out. 15 minutes later, Henry arrives at the restaurant, texting Elisa that he's here... Elisa was still on the couch. Another 15 minutes later, Elisa texts, "walking in now, where are you at?" As she steps through the door, their eyes meet through the empty restaurant, and they knew they were each others' dates. -- One month and many on-time dates later -- Henry and Elisa decide to officially become boyfriend and girlfriend on October 20, 2018. That same night, Elisa states, "Oh, I guess I should give you my real name and phone number now..." -- Jump to April 2025 -- Henry proposes and Elisa says "Yes!"