Hay started going to yoga at SHY and she became friends with Holly, who was Billy’s realtor/friend. Hay and Holl went out on a lady date and Hay asked Holly if she knew anyone for her to date. Billy ran into Holly a week later and asked the same question. Holly decided to play cupid. On May 14, 2019 Billy messaged Hay. The two of them talked everyday for a month before finally meeting up. Billy actually cancelled their first date for an asthma attack and Hay realized how perfect they were for each other. Billy came up to Ocean City to meet Hay and Sadie for their first date and they have been together ever since. Fast forward two years later, a lot of miles rode, inhalers puffed, and waves caught, Billy got down on one knee and proposed to Hay at Higbee beach April 25.