Sarah had just moved in with her new roommate and tagged along to karaoke night at Bingham Tavern. In the group was a cute guy she assumed was taken. Wanting to be a good sport, Sarah decided to join in and embarrass herself publicly by singing karaoke and chose "Big Poppa" by the Notorious BIG and mixed up all the words except "I see some ladies tonight that should be having my baby, baaabbbyyyy." Jim, presumably, watched with cartoon hearts in his eyes. At some point he went in for the classic move: "you want a Miller Lite?" As everyone else left the bar one by one, just Sarah and Jim were left and she though "oh, he's definitely into me." She then asked if he wanted to explore Mt. Washington with her the next day and they went on their first date and shared ice cream and talked about their love of NPR and how firefighters don't really rescue cats from trees that often.