Although their paths crossed as teenagers, Kelsey and Guitano's friendship blossomed into something more at her homecoming barbeque. He showed up on her doorstep with a rose from his garden, and she was smitten.

On a vacation in Jamaica, after a light evening rainfall, Kelsey and Guitano went down to the beach for a glass of wine. As the sun began to set on the beautiful Caribbean water, Guitano got down one knee and popped the question. Kelsey joyfully said YES!