Christine and Andrew met on the dating app Hinge, where they first connected over a shared love of reality TV. Their first date was at City Tap House on April 8, 2023. After a few hours of easy conversation, they decided to continue their date at Victory Brewing Co. They were so caught up talking that by the time they were ready to order dinner, the kitchen had already closed. Andrew promised that their next date would include a proper meal. Three days later, he took Christine to Pepperoncini for their second date. On September 9, 2023, Andrew officially asked Christine to be his girlfriend after introducing her to his friends at a Phillies game. A year later, they moved in together in their favorite town, Conshohocken, where they later bought their forever home. Andrew proposed during a trip to Italy with Christine’s family on May 3, 2025. He had planned to propose on Tre Ponti Bridge in Burano, but he had to improvise when the bridge was too crowded. They eventually came across a quiet bridge surrounded by colorful houses. Andrew got down on one knee while Christine was distracted taking photos. She said yes, and they celebrated that evening with a romantic dinner along the Grand Canal in Venice.