A little bit of a drive, but totally worth it if you want to try the freshest seafood & Greg's pick for the best lobster and clam chowder. Menemsha is a working fishing village (think fishing boats & lobster traps) with spectacular sunsets.
Chappy is completely cutoff from the main island of Martha's Vineyard and only accessible by a very short ferry ride. It's great for a bike ride and some beautiful beaches with calm waters.
Located on Upper Main St in Edgartown, the upstairs is a bit formal but downstairs is a cool tavern with great burgers. If you're on the hunt for a celebrity sighting, Atria is your best chance.
Jewelry, Souvenirs, Clothing & More (plus face time with wedding officiant & store owner - Scott!)