The two met through mutual friend groups at a Saturday evening shindig. Caleb and his shenanigans had the group outside to do some cowboy jousting. His liquid courage mixed with a desire to talk to Payton resulted in an extended challenge to joust. After a quick exchange of trash talk between the two, the game was on. Both started at each other, loops spinning overhead. Payton threw an almost textbook heel shot, barely missing its target. Caleb, however, took a much bolder approach and went for a header toss (which is not how the game is supposed to be played). His looped sailed and landed perfectly on the bridge of Payton's nose. After Payton tossed some choice words at Caleb, the two laughed the event off. Since then, they have been inseparable.