You might get a different version of the story depending on who you ask—but both Sarah and Grant agree that it all began in Cleveland’s Tremont neighborhood, where they both lived at the time. Sarah was working at Tremont Athletic Club, and Grant happened to be a member. They also both frequented the neighborhood hangout, Treehouse. Sarah insists they met at Treehouse, where she remembers Grant buying her a drink. Excited that he might be interested in her, she told a friend. The friend’s response? “That’s just how he is. He buys everyone drinks.” Meanwhile, Grant remembers noticing Sarah at the gym. He thought she was into him because she always smiled and waved. When he brought that up later, Sarah laughed and told him, “Oh, honey, I was working. I smiled and waved at everyone.” It’s a wonder these two ever got together—but somehow, they did. And once they finally connected, the rest was history.