Grace and José met at an ugly Christmas sweater party that Grace and her college roommates hosted. José and his group of friends showed up in the same Walmart turtlenecks that Grace was wearing! José and Grace became Facebook friends that night and stayed acquaintances for the next five years. Grace was a regular at Lazy Moon and would occasionally get a free slice if José was working. In December of 2017, while golfing, Jose's groomsman Matt said "If I make this next putt...you've gotta make a move." One week later José and Grace went on their first date and have been together ever since.