Jake had just stepped off of a flight from California. But, jet lagged, he decided to go and celebrate a friend's birthday. He sat next to Erin and they ended up chatting the night away. After a first date of coffee turned into dinner (+ ice cream!), they knew they had found something special.

With the knowledge that Erin would feel incredibly awkward about a public proposal, he proposed quietly, alone at her childhood home. They celebrated at their favorite Pittsburgh restaurant, the Vandal!