Sarah and Erich met on the dating app, Coffee Meets Bagel, right before Sarah moved to Boston. Erich insists that Sarah "cat-fished" him since they matched before Sarah lived in Boston. Sarah continues to tell him that's not what cat-fishing is. It took several weeks before they were able to meet in person since Erich postponed their first date due to his "man cold." They finally had their first date on October 13, 2018 at Bourbon's Kitchen and Cocktails in Framingham followed by dessert at Ben & Jerry's and have been together ever since!