Brock took Melissa to one of her favorite restaurants in Indianapolis, chosen for its outdoor seating (which would soon become significant). After they finished dinner, "Love Story" by Taylor Swift started playing on a violin right behind Melissa. She quickly turned around, surprised, and asked, "What is going on?" By the time she faced Brock again, he was already on one knee, pulling a ring from his pocket. After a long hug, some tears, and initially placing the ring on the wrong finger, Melissa joyfully said yes!