Their first date was the Saturday before Halloween. Elizabeth arrived at the restaurant first, only to find all restaurant workers and guests decked out in Halloween costumes. Elizabeth texted Collin, "I hope you dressed up". Collin wasn't sure if she was joking (she was, she always is). They enjoyed their dinner, surrounded by cowboys, superheroes, and Frankenstein. Collin and Elizabeth returned to the restaurant to celebrate their one-year anniversary, still the only patrons not in costume. Fast forward, Collin proposed on November 1, 2019 (the day after Halloween), and it only seemed fitting to plan a wedding around the time of year that it all started. This time, Elizabeth and Collin will be the only ones in costumes - they're going as Bride and Groom.