Mandy and Jimmy first met during Summer 2014 working at Outdoor Adventure, a summer camp. Their favorite game at camp was "Calling All Cars", dodgeball with a twist. Jimmy would throw out his arm every time, and Mandy enjoyed watching her favorite counselor hit children in the face with a ball. They worked alongside each other for the summer, but didn't talk much until after camp had finished. One night back at school, Mandy and Jimmy spent the whole night talking and getting to know each other. It's uncertain who felt the butterflies first, but by the end of the night, Mandy and Jimmy came to realize how they felt for each other.

After a night at the ballet with friends, Mandy came home to a candlelit apartment. Mandy was greeted at the door by James Arthur and MAX, singing "Say You Won't Let Go" and "Lights Down Low," respectively. Jimmy was dressed to the nines, and told Mandy that he needed to talk to her about something important. After professing his love for her, Jimmy got down on one knee and asked "Mandy Nasser, will you marry me?" Without hesitation, Mandy said "Yes!" and struggled to see the ring in the dimly lit apartment.