David found Kelly online. All she had was a picture of half of her face covered by her dog, Chubby, and it was enough. David said he was really good at math and proved it by doing her Doctorate level Pharmaceutical Calculations homework for 3 months. Kelly aced the class, and finally, David and Kelly went on their first date.

The ring came in the mail and Kelly answered the door. The package was atypical since it required a signature, so Kelly knew exactly what it was. David and Kelly had a Disneyland trip scheduled two weeks later, and Kelly was expecting to be proposed at Disneyland. David knew of Kelly's expectation and surprised Kelly by immediately opened the package and proposing in the living room.