Jenna thought it was going to be another Saturday evening going out with some good friends to a nice restaurant in Harrisburg. As they were about to leave Dalton's house, he conveniently remembered he promised to do a favor for someone and pick up an order of chocolates at the Mummert Chocolates shop for an event the next day. Jenna naturally thought this was completely normal and agreed to leave a little early. Upon arriving to the chocolate shop, she soon realized that the entire shop was decorated with candles, rose pedals, and the like. Before she could take it all in, Dalton was on one knee, feeling more anxious than ever. After he finally got through his proposal, Jenna said "Yes!".