Natalie and Kyle met in their High-School German class when Kyle was 16 and Natalie was 15. Both of them were in the process of planning a class trip to Germany that year. This is where Natalie and Kyle first began talking and getting to know each other and hanging out. Later on, Natalie and Kyle would begin talking about anything just to keep talking to each other and have been the same way ever since.

Natalie and Kyle's first date was getting dropped off at Target since neither of them were old enough to drive yet. They spent the date walking around the store and shopping for Christmas gifts and wrapping paper. After a couple hours in the store, and a break at Starbucks, the only thing they ended up buying was Disney themed wrapping paper which they still have not used...

On their way to a NY Giants game against the Atlanta Falcons, Kyle proposed to Natalie. Both teams being bottom of their division made it likely to be an interesting game. Natalie, being a diehard Giants fan, cheered any chance she got for the Giants as well as booed any chance she got at the Falcons....and mostly the referees. Even though the Giants ended up losing in the last minute, it was still a perfect day.