Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Hero Image 1Hero Image 2
Trees

Nathaniel

Cramer

and

Abigail

Holaus

#CallUsCramer

September 5, 2026

Peninsula, OH
83 days83 d16 hours16 h49 minutes49 min52 seconds52 s

It All Started with a Swipe

We met on Hinge—just one of those matches that felt easy right from the start. Conversation flowed naturally for a few days, the kind where you don’t have to overthink what to say next. At one point, in the middle of talking about our favorite restaurants, Nathaniel asked if it would be okay if he got Abbey's number. It felt simple and genuine, so of course she said yes. Not long after, Nathaniel asked Abbey out—Zappitelli’s for dinner, then maybe pool and drinks after. It sounded like the perfect mix of laid-back and thoughtful. Our first date started at Zappitelli’s, and it honestly couldn’t have gone better. Dinner turned into hours of talking and laughing, the kind where you forget to check your phone or notice time passing. Afterward, we set out to find a place to play pool… which turned into driving all around the city, hopping from place to place, only to find everything way too crowded. Eventually, we laughed it off and ended up right back near where we started—at the bar next to Zappitelli’s. But the real moment came the next day. We spent the whole day together, just enjoying each other’s company, wandering through the mall, talking about everything and nothing. And at one point, before going to Nathaniel's house, he mentioned wanting to stop home first—just to vacuum, so his cats wouldn’t bother Abbey's allergies. It was such a small thing, but it said everything. That was the moment Abbey knew—he was the one. And as it turns out, Nathaniel knew even earlier—he knew the moment he asked her out that she was the one.

Footer image