Cristi and Conroy both decided to give online dating a try after many failed relationships. One day Conroy messaged Cristi saying how loyal she is for being a NY Knicks fan. After many conversations, and video chats they decided to go on their first date. Most people go to a nice dinner and a movie on their first date. Conroy decided to take Cristi to a shooting range in New Jersey. He picked her up and as soon as they met in person the vibe was instant. A few months later they both decided to delete the app and make their relationship official. Then in August 2020 Conroy and Cristi went hiking together and after many hours made it to a high point that overlooked the area. It was there where Conroy took his profile pic on his online profile where Cristi swiped right. It was also the spot where Conroy proposed to Cristi. He made her work for that ring!