It was New Years Eve in Chicago at a small bar in Lakeview, and Colleen came up to Nick ... or Nick came up to Colleen ... who knows! What we do know is that Nick asked Colleen to dance, and she said only if he could best her in a duel of skill - rock, paper scissors! Nick used rock, Colleen used scissors - and the rest is happily ever after! They were each other's midnight kiss that evening and haven't looked back since.