Paul and Chase met in 2008 while they were students at Ursuline High School. They were both asked to give a speech on being a student-athlete during UHS 8th grade day. Chase gave a spectacular speech, as expected, while Paul put on the worst display of a speech anyone has ever seen. Paul's little brother, Anthony, was in the audience as an 8th grader and was too embarrassed to admit to anyone that he was related to Paul. While the speech was terrible, this was the moment that Paul and Chase met and fell for each other. Not long after, Chase attended one of Paul's baseball games and everyone headed to the royal gardens after. While eating wings and grumpy Joe's, Chase asked Paul out to go golfing with her. Fortunately for Paul, it rained so he didn't have to embarrass himself on the golf course. The first date was moved to BW3 downtown, and the rest was history. Twelve years later, Paul proposed on their back deck with the help of their dog Sully.