It all started back in 2018 at Elmira College, where Olivia and Dan found themselves at the same party. Dan was eager to show off his latest party trick—the pistol squat—but he underestimated Olivia’s competitive spirit. Never one to back down from a challenge, Olivia took him on and, despite being in heels, effortlessly out-squatted him. After Olivia headed home, Dan realized he’d made a major mistake: he never got her number. Fortunately, he tracked her down on Instagram, sent a DM, and the rest is history