We met on a dating app! We know. We know. How very Gen Z. Caylin saw photos of Nathan swimming competitively on his profile, and she had also grown up swimming. The photo was of him swimming the same stroke she had specialized in, so she used that as a conversation starter when she sent him the initial message. They met up at Blaze Pizza for their first date, and that date lasted for nearly five hours. It only ended when the restaurant closed, and Nathan and Caylin both knew this was something special. They realized on the date that they had been swimming in the same competitions for years. They had even coached children's teams that swam in the same competitions after they both became summer league coaches after graduating high school. Turns out they had been in each other's lives all along and just never known that their other half was closer than they could have imagined.