Our story began the way many great love stories do these days: with some very strategic Instagram story likes. She liked his, he liked hers, and eventually Zack took the hint and slid into Caylie's DMs—on his own birthday. They talked nonstop for a week and a half until Caylie's birthday rolled around and she "accidentally" ghosted him. But God clearly had a plan, because that very night they bumped into each other at a bar in Cleveland. One completely unexpected moment turned into the start of something they never could’ve planned themselves, but now couldn’t imagine life any other way!