Mateo and Cassi first met at Oconomowoc High School in 2018 over something very on-brand for them: music. Cassi asked Mateo to show her a specific playlist, only to immediately joke that she had one that was better than his anyway. What started as an easy back-and-forth over music turned into a friendship that kept growing long after high school. A year later, fate stepped in again when Mateo ended up rooming with several of Cassi’s guy friends in college. After months of spending time together almost every day — hanging out, laughing, and becoming inseparable without really meaning to — their friendship turned into something more. On May 19, 2019, they officially started dating, and the rest has been unfolding ever since.