Prior to their first date, Cole and Casie crossed paths months before at The Lift, a bar they both frequented. Not much was exchanged (besides a failed attempt at exchanging numbers), but they both knew something was there. Fast forward to February 2018 when Cole literally slid into Casie's DMs on Instagram and they started chatting. Finally, the first date was set for early March in 2018, and yadda, yadda, yadda, the rest is history. (Check out the photo at the bottom of this page - this photo was taken in the very booth they sat at on their first date!)
Cole proposed right outside of The Lift, the bar where they first crossed. It was in the exact same spot where Casie said "no" to Cole giving her his number back in 2017. But this time she said "yes" to marrying him. He then surprised her with a gathering inside the bar with her closest family and friends. It was the perfect night!