While Brendan will say their first real date was a Jack Johnson concert, they met at Little City Brewing the night before. Clearly, he was so smitten they had to go to see Jack Johnson live the next night. When you know, you know, right?

Walking with the boys on Historic Occoneechee Speedway Trail, Brendan proposed. It was simple, sweet, private and to the point. Casey may have skipped to the car afterwards.