Tucker had asked Cassy if they could take some nice photos together for a Christmas card. Cassy took her time getting ready, wanting everything to be perfect in her favorite holiday dress. Just as they were about to leave, Tucker told her their friends, Ryan and Seth, couldn’t take the photos because their dog, Oakley—whom Cassy adores—was very sick. Distracted and worried, Cassy completely forgot about the photos. What she didn’t know was that it was all part of Tucker’s plan. He took her to their favorite spot, a rock wall overlooking the ocean. With Ryan and Seth secretly waiting nearby with a camera, Tucker asked for a quick selfie. As Cassy leaned in, he got down on one knee and asked her to marry him. And the rest is history.