Phoenix sent Carli a Facebook message asking to take her out to get tacos. Carli obviously tried to play hard to get (even after telling all her girls how cute she thought he was) and asked for a rain check. Well we all know Phoenix, he’s persistent when he knows what he wants! So, he didn’t give up…a week later, Carli & Phoenix went on their first date. They spent the entire day together and immediately became inseparable. From there, the rest was history!