They were in Nashville, Tennessee, celebrating Carley's 21st birthday. Joshua had planned to propose on the first night at the rooftop pool, but the hotel staff asked them to leave because the pool was closed. The next day, he took Carley to the top of the bridge overlooking the river. While she was gazing over the edge, Joshua got down on one knee. When she turned around and saw him, she immediately started crying and said yes as soon as he asked her to marry him.