One day Candice and Connor matched on Bumble. Candice never messaged Connor. But Connor was brave enough to message Candice on her Instagram account. A few chats later the first date was at Sanzaris. It went so well that the two decided to get drinks at Biagio's... shocker. The topic of sports came up while the two were getting to know one another. Ironically, they both realized they were at the same Yankee - Red Sox home opener 5 nights prior. They both were at the same bar before the game with their friends... Billys. Candice mentioned how these men were doing tequila shots next to them while her and her friend Jessica had a great time. Candice showed a video to Connor of Jessica dancing at the bar and Connor paused the video, pointing out that there was him and his friends Joe and Sean; admitting that they were the tequila shooters. Candice and Connor both realized that if they were not not there at the same time, Bumble would not have shown them in their locations. The Yankees may have lost that night, but there was a win for Candice and Connor. So was it Bumble, or Billys?