Logan and Caitlyn were spending the summer of 2016 at the Jersey Shore. However, their summers were very different. Caitlyn was spending it with her family in Normandy Beach while Logan had a share house in Manasquan with 20 other guys from his hometown in Summit. Caitlyn went out a few weekends with her cousin Callie, also from Summit, to the popular summer spot Osprey. One Saturday night Caitlyn and Callie were hanging out by the same bar as Logan and his friends. Logan was trying to get Caitlyn's attention with little luck. It wasn't until Logan joined Caitlyn on the dance floor that made the difference. Two days later, Logan asked Caitlyn to attend a Justin Bieber Concert that very night. Nothing like a first date to one of the biggest concerts that summer to win a girl over. 10 days later, they said I Love You.