Cait and Jeff first met while each starting their careers in Philly. Jeff (unknowingly) asked Cait out on their first date to her favorite Mexican restaurant, Mission Taqueria. There, they shared (in Cait's opinion), the city's best margaritas. Little did Cait know, Jeff hated margaritas! But needless to say, he must have liked Cait because they went out on their second date just one day later. And from there, you could say the rest is history...