When Cait moved back in with her parents in New Jersey and took a job at ShopRite, she thought this was just a time to get through until something better came along. She had no idea this would be where she would meet the love of her life. After years of seeing each other in passing and a handful of quick interchanges, they still didn't so much as know each other's names. That was until one fateful day, when an alarm light began blinking. With no knowledge of what the blinking light meant (and no knowledge of what Shawn ACTUALLY did there), Cait remarked to the store's maintenance manager, Steve, "Does that mean that the hot guy who does the lights will have to come back to fix it?" On November 5th, 2013, Shawn came back (though not to fix the light). It was a happy coincidence because he was rarely sent to work in this particular store. Despite his fear that she would turn out to be a stuck-up priss, he asked for her phone number (in front of a very awkwardly gawking, but adorable little old woman). Cait obliged and EVEN answered his call that afternoon! Though she usually would have put it off or made up some excuse not to go that night, something told Cait to go for it. She was incredibly nervous, especially because she'd never been on a real date before! He picked her up that night, and off they went. It was a bit of a rocky start, but the date ended up being perfect in its imperfections, and neither wanted the night to end. They talked late into the night, shared their first kiss, and stayed at the restaurant until it closed. Since then, they've hardly ever been apart. Although she'd never imagined herself with children, Cait surprised even herself by how quickly she fell in love with Shawn's son, Austin. They now share a home, a family, and a zoo of pets... As they prepared for a fishing trip on September 23rd, 2017, Shawn got down on one knee and asked Cait to spend the rest of her life with him. As if there was ever any question!