Once upon a swipe, AJ found Caitlin on Hinge. His pictures? Let’s just say… they didn’t exactly scream “HD romance.” Caitlin was skeptical, but his ginger hair made her curious enough to say yes to pizza. When they met, AJ talked. A lot. Like, a lot a lot. Caitlin remembers thinking, “Is he nervous, or is this just… him?” Still, between bites of pepperoni and endless conversation, something about him felt easy. Caitlin wasn’t sure about a 2nd date, but decided to give him a second chance. And that’s when it started to happen. Slowly at first, then somehow all at once, she found herself falling for him. AJ loved how Caitlin takes charge (his words: “bossy in the cutest way possible”), and she loved how thoughtful and caring he was about everything. Now we laugh about that first date — the bad photos, the nonstop talking, the unexpected magic in between. Because somewhere between the slices and the second chance, we found the love of our lives.