It was a modern day "You've Got Mail." Lauren's maid of honor Kat Coplen was looking through messages on Lauren's Match.com and came across a note saying "You're Cute ^^ What's Your Favorite Peanut Butter?" (Lauren had, of course, written about her love of peanut butter on her profile.) Katherine took one look at Andy's profile, saw he looked like a perfect match for her BFF--and he even played the violin! So, she said, "Let's message him back." And the rest, as they say, was history ... and they've been sharing jars of peanut butter-- natural crunchy, please--ever since.